Reviewed by Pauline Hosking
In his publicity blurb the author writes that this
book is primarily aimed at YA readers and anyone above the age of twelve. Young
readers are interested in stories about people their own age or a few years
older. Even though this book is titled Jemma,
who is the youngest daughter in the Palette family, the main character in all
the stories is Dad, a middle-aged writer of fiction.
Early in the second story we learn that Mum is in
hospital with some undiagnosed problem. The story then focuses on Jemma meeting
an old sea captain who sets her a riddle. The riddle’s answer will explain how humans
should spend their lives. The story is thus high-jacked by adults, with the
riddle being solved by Mum. (Her illness had been caused by the family dog’s
new herbicidal shampoo).
The third story is a variation on Six Characters in Search of an Author, with the imaginary Palette
family talking to the author.
The fourth story, which has the most potential for
8-12 year olds, concerns the theft of a golden eagle. Jemma plays more of a
role here, but at the climax of the story, instead of being actively involved
in saving the eagle, she and her friends retreat to eat pizza and wait
patiently for news.
This book would probably work best for an adult audience.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Buzz Words Books would love to hear what you think.